Tuesday, 07 August 2012 00:00

School at Home or Homeschooling?

Written by 

Over the past several years an educational phenomenon has been exploding across America. Fed up with the homogenized, secular indoctrination; embrace of dysfunctional and sexualized behavior; and tolerance for rebellious and unruly children that largely define public education in the United States, an increasing number of parents are pulling their kids out of the local schools and opting instead for a home education plan.

According to Dr. Brian Ray of the National Home Education Research Institute (NHERI), as of 2010 there were, by best estimates, over two million homeschooled students ages five to 18 in the United States, with the population of home educated students growing by up to six percent every year. While the reasons parents choose to teach their kids at home may vary, what is clear is that homeschooled kids outshine their public-schooled counterparts on just about every level.

Home-educated students typically score 15 to 30 points above public-school students on standardized achievement tests — and they do so regardless of their parents’ level of formal education. These taught-at-home students also typically score above the average on the SAT and ACT tests colleges use for admission — which means that most universities love having them, and in many cases actively recruit them. And while opponents warn that homeschooled students miss out on crucial opportunities for socialization provided in a public-school setting, the truth is that children educated at home typically score above average in tests of social, emotional, and psychological development.

Dr. Ray told The New American that increasingly parents throughout the United States are turning toward home-based education because “they want solid academics for their children, values and worldview that they choose rather than what the state chooses, stronger family relationships, and individualized education rather than a one-size-fits-all system.” He added that many concerned parents are fed up with the lax behavioral standards prevalent in most public schools.

Over the past 30 years, the traditional homeschool model has earned a reputation for providing the foundation many parents want for their children. With the help of private, free-market homeschool curriculums like A Beka, Bob Jones, A.C.E., and Alpha Omega — all with Christian foundations — tens of thousands of families raised a generation of Americans with solid academics, along with crucial scriptural training and the principles of Americanism that are essential to the nation’s future.

As homeschooling gained widespread popularity throughout the 1990s, the public-education establishment found it increasingly difficult to stop the exodus of families seeking something better for their children. But with the introduction of online learning in the late 1990s, a core of education “entrepreneurs” suggested that, using the charter-school concept, public schools might just offer their own version of homeschooling that would allow students to fulfill all the requirements set by a district — but instead of going to a classroom they could use an online curriculum.

One of those entrepreneurs was former U.S. Education Secretary William Bennett, who in 1999 helped found a company called K12, which has gone on to be a leading player in what has become known as the “Virtual Academy.” Companies like K12 contract with school districts to provide curriculum and education consultants, in return reaping part of the local, state, and federal tax money that the district gets for each student. The families that sign on to these public-school virtual academies get “free homeschooling” for their kids — which typically includes “free” computers and other perks — while the school district retains the per-student monies it would have lost had those families gone with another homeschool option. It all sounds like a win-win scenario, right?

Wrong! Companies like K12 and Connections Academy have exerted great effort to convince the public that they are providing a quality homeschool option through public schools.

But homeschool experts point out that these public-school virtual academies have little in common with traditional homeschooling. Dr. Ray noted that while traditional homeschooling has always been privately funded and privately pursued, public-school virtual academies are tax-funded, state-run, and state-controlled. Ray emphasized that in the virtual academy model, “the state chooses and controls the curriculum — that which is used to teach, train, and indoctrinate the student.”

By contrast, he said, “in home-based education and private schools, parents and private organizations get to decide what is used to teach, train, and indoctrinate children. The center of power and control with a virtual academy is the state; in private education, it is parents, family, and freely-chosen private associations.”

While K12 boasts that online public school offers “powerful choices for parents,” and other virtual academies insist that their curricula give parents and students flexibility, a majority of those “choices” and flexibility are lost when it comes to one important element that has always been essential to a majority of homeschool parents: Christian instruction. Israel Wayne, a noted education expert, author, and publisher of the Home School Digest, explained that when parents contract with a state-run virtual academy to teach their kids, they are essentially surrendering their right to teach biblical concepts to their children in their homes (or elsewhere) during the scheduled school day.

And why is that? Students enrolled in a virtual academy are part of a charter school, and “any school that receives government funds is prohibited by law from allowing what is considered to be sectarian religious teaching,” Wayne said.

In addition, since online students are enrolled in a local school district, and are under the direction of teachers assigned through the school (parents are merely “learning coaches”), they are susceptible to whatever social indoctrination the school deems important for students to embrace — from the prevailing attitudes on homosexuality, contraception, and abortion, to the science curriculum’s take on evolution.

Virtually all experts and leaders in the traditional homeschool community have condemned K12-style public-school virtual academies as an unworkable option for parents who want a homeschool experience for their children that they control and guide.

The Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA), the leading organization defending the rights of homeschool families, has strongly cautioned parents against enrolling their children in virtual charter schools. “Many homeschoolers are seduced by attractive marketing and forget that virtual charter schools are actually controlled by the public school system,” said a recent HSLDA article on online charter schools. The organization added that it “does not represent students enrolled in full-time charter school ­programs.”

While K12/Connections-style virtual academies may be a bad fit for homeschoolers, there are, nonetheless, some online homeschool curricula that not only provide solid academics, but which also reinforce the Christian and Americanist values a majority of homeschool parents say they want for their kids.

One of the most recent is FreedomProject Education (FPE), a K-12 online curriculum that combines basic academic subjects with disciplines that hearken back to the classical tradition of past generations. In fact, the motto for FPE is “A Classical Education in the Tradition of America’s Founders,” and its stated mission is to empower students “to understand, enjoy, and preserve the freedom and moral responsibility embodied in America’s founding principles.”

FPE founder Alan Scholl noted that the program offers the basic courses parents would expect in any quality homeschool curriculum. “But we also offer solid college prep classes like logic, American Studies, Latin and other foreign languages, and even Biblical Studies,” he said. “FreedomProject is classical education for the modern age, the kind of education George Washington and our Founding Fathers received. And it’s all delivered with a state-of-the-art online learning system.”

Scholl said that with many parents in search of a solid curriculum that will prepare their kids for the future, they need look no further that FPE. “We have taken great care to design a curriculum that teaches solid academics, along with the fundamentals of liberty, citizenship, and Americanist-minded independence,” he said. “The flexible, affordable, and high- quality alternative to government education is here, for anyone who is seeking a better way to educate their children, or supplement their own efforts through homeschooling.”

For more information about FreedomProject Education, visit FPEUSA.org.

This article is an example of the exclusive content that's only available by subscribing to our print magazine. Twice a month get in-depth features covering the political gamut: education, candidate profiles, immigration, healthcare, foreign policy, guns, etc. Digital as well as print options are available!


  • Comment Link Tina Tuesday, 07 August 2012 17:00 posted by Tina

    We are part of a virtual cyber school (connections) and we have also done K12. I have to disagree with your statement that we HAVE to teach what is in the text. We do not! If there is something that we disagree with or we don't want to teach our children, the school is fair and let's the child do a report on a different subject. For instance, evolution...the teacher will let the child do a report on why they don't agree with evolution. Also if there is a novel that you don't want your child to read, they will work with you to find one that suits you. You can also supplement the curriculum for Bible studies. I buy a bible homeschool curriculum and work that into our day. We live in a not so friendly homeschooling state (pa) and this works out better. Also my children work harder because they have to answer to someone else other than just "mom"

  • Comment Link Joaquin Fernandez Tuesday, 07 August 2012 07:41 posted by Joaquin Fernandez

    I recently produced an award-winning documentary, "IndoctriNation: Public Schools and the Decline of Christianity in America." The film includes a fascinating account of where the government school system came from by Samuel Blumenfeld. It also analyses, with the help of John Taylor Gatto, how scientific experimentation took over education in the 1800's. Other interviewees include Neal McCluskey from the CATO Institute and three-time presidential candidate Howard Phillips from the Conservative Caucus.

    We also include first-hand accounts from whistleblower public school teachers and administrators, as well as students and parents, including the father of a boy who was killed at Columbine in 1999.

    The film is told as a road movie as it follows Colin Gunn, a Scottish homeschool father now living in Texas, on a field trip across the USA in a big yellow school bus.

    Here's the film's intro: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8jhqMQwAiJ4&list=UUp8cIB61NCs4TjmBbtW9VEA&index=8&feature=plcp

  • Comment Link Nick Tuesday, 07 August 2012 03:52 posted by Nick

    Thanks so much for the interesting read.

    As homeschoolers ourselves one of the first things we encountered when we started was the confusing situation of so many companies trying to get us to buy their products most of which were too mainstream for us and so similar to what is taught in schools that it lacks the vibrancy to keep children interested in their learning. And we know many home educators that are finding the same.

    It can be both frustrating and overwhelming.

    Fortunately about 9 months ago we discovered the subject of Visual Learning and the online video resources offered by a company called Zane Education - and seriously we have never looked back. My 2 kids find the use of online video so much more interesting and compelling, that they have both taken a much great interest in what they are learning. And more than anything we are finding that the use of the subtitled video enables both Toby who is now 12, and Lucy who is just 8, to study a range of curriculum topics AND improve their reading at the same time ...something we have not found anywhere else.

    Zane Education provides Visual Learning - a method of online learning that includes the use of online subtitled educational video that caters for virtually all Learning Styles. The online educational videos which deliver the curriculum material, are accompanied by online multiple choice quizzes, lesson plans and interactive study tools. As well as providing an ideal online education solution and curriculum for homeschool education it also caters for special needs education because the child has the choice of watching, listenting to, or reading each presentation.

    The use of online video also enables each child to study at their own speed which my wife and I sincerely believe is the key to helping any child achieve their greatest potential.

    They operate using online subscription which effectively enables you to educate the who family for under $200 per year regardless of how many children you have.

    I wholeheartedly recommend Homeschooling for anyone that is seriously interested in the educational welfare and future for their kids - if for no other reason than all children have different skills and abilities - and those require indiviual care and attention to nurture them and bring out the best in them. The factory line approach taken by the traditional school system does not allow for this and it is why so many kids today are becoming frustrated with what's on offer in schools. And this is a major reason for their disinterest.

    So for any one interested in making education more interesting and effective for their children, go and take a look at this link...


    Hope it works as well for you as it has for us.

Please Log In To Comment
Log in