Thursday, 02 August 2012 00:00

WikiLeaks' Syria Files: Embarrassing to West, Irrelevant in Syria

Written by 

WikiLeaks' “Syria Files,” 2.4 million e-mails purloined from anonymous Syrian government sources, seem destined to have a greater impact on the West than on Syria. The headlines thus far have left a black mark on the U.S.-based Vogue magazine as well as the New York City-based public relations firm Brown Lloyd James.

The PR firm had suggested to the Syrian government an “open hands initiative” approach to the protests already evident in May 2011, and asked that Syrian First Lady Asma al-Assad get involved in the public relations effort. Brown Lloyd James' contract reputedly resulted in the Vogue magazine puff-piece “A Rose in the Desert,” a propaganda photo-shoot and profile that the magazine took off the Web after its propaganda purpose became widely known.

Italian technology conglomerate Selex also found itself in the public opinion crosshairs. The Spanish newspaper Publico reported July 6 that “Italian Selex Communications and its partner Intracom Telecom Greco-Russian installed communications technology for military use” in Syria, especially the TETRA secure communications system that is now likely being used to organize against protesters. Publico also noted that the Italian computer conglomerate helped refine the TETRA system for the Iranian government as well.

When WikiLeaks began releasing its “Syria Files” July 3 (the organization is continuing to release the files in stages), the organization's spokesman boasted that “the Syria files shine a light on the inner workings of the Syrian government and economy, but they also reveal how the West and Western companies say one thing and do another.”

The latter part of the above statement may be the greatest legacy of the “Syria Files,” as Syria was not prepared to make maximum use of the WikiLeaks files. Unlike the highly wired and highly educated Tunisia, Syria is near the bottom of the Arabic world in Internet connectivity — “4,469,000 Internet users in Syria as of June 2011 for a 19.8% Internet penetration rate,” according to Wikipedia. Only Yemen and Iraq have a lower wired percentage of the population in the Arab world.

Unlike the WikiLeaks release in advance of the Tunisian revolution (which did help spark that nation's revolution), the July 3 release of the Syrian files was far too late to spark the Syrian revolt. By the time the documents were published, the Syrian protests had already been underway for a year. Indeed, the military phase of the revolution had already been underway for months. 

What is clear from the Syrian civil war is the heavy price of gun control laws in a nation. Only three percent of Syrian citizens were authorized to possess firearms, mostly only members of the ruling Baathist Party and its friends. As a result, government forces have been able to torture protesters with impunity, and even to kill them. In one video published by the London Guardian last year, a protester said he was told by government forces detaining him: “You can't defend yourself. It's too easy, we can kill you.” Another asked the English reporter: “People being faced by the army, by weapons, how do they resist?” Of course, where the opposition has gained access to weapons, it has engaged in murder as well.

Finally, the “Syria Files” reveal the close connection between the Assad regime's Baath Party and the Syrian Communist Party. The Syrian Communist Party remains solidly behind the Assad regime, declaring in a June 2011 e-mail that "this attack on Syria, which takes multiple faces such as political pressure, military threats, economic sabotage, and hatching conspiracies to bring out radical transformations to change Syrian national face, including the overthrow of the current regime which based on the wide national alliance its primary aim to protect and strengthen national sovereignty.” The Communist Party communique said of the Assad regime: “Syria was and still forms the main obstacle in the Arabs against enslavement [under a] new great Middle East plan.” The Syrian Communist Party also condemned Islamic parties arising across the Middle East, especially the Muslim Brotherhood. “Turkey embraces reactionary groups that disguised by religion like Muslim Brotherhood, which share the ruling party in Turkey its thought and loyalty to imperialism,” the Syrian Communist Party Central Committee ranted.

1 comment

  • Comment Link REMant Thursday, 02 August 2012 17:02 posted by REMant

    Given the fact that the Sunnis comprise 3/4 of the population, I would suppose that we'd have seen revolt and reprisals a lot sooner than this had they all been armed, unless, of course the effect of it was to promote sensibility. It is hard to say when a ppl is ready for peace and freedom. Tho it is certain that dictatorship is not the way to maintain it. With any luck the experience of the past four decades will prove salutary.

Please Log In To Comment
Log in